It is also true that in the real world investors in stocks don't usually get
to buy at book value. Sometimes they have been able to buy in below book;
usually, however, they've had to pay more than book, and when that happens
there is further pressure on that 12%. I'll talk more about these relationships
later. Meanwhile, let's focus on the main point: as inflation has increased,
the return on equity capital has not. Essentially, those who buy equities
receive securities with an underlying fixed return just like those who buy
bonds.
Of course, there are some important differences between the bond and stock
forms. For openers, bonds eventually come due. It may require a long wait, but
eventually the bond investor gets to renegotiate the terms of his contract. If
current and prospective rates of inflation make his old coupon look inadequate,
he can refuse to play further unless coupons currently being offered rekindle
his interest. Something of this sort has been going on in recent years.
Stocks, on the other hand, are perpetual. They have a maturity date of
infinity. Investors in stocks are stuck with whatever return corporate America
happens to earn. If corporate America is destined to earn 12%, then that is the
level investors must learn to live with.
As a group, stock investors can neither opt out nor renegotiate.
In the aggregate, their commitment is actually increasing. Individual companies
can be sold or liquidated and corporations can repurchase their own shares; on
balance, however, new equity flotations and retained earnings guarantee that
the equity capital locked up in the corporate system will increase.
So, score one for the bond form. Bond coupons eventually will be
renegotiated; equity "coupons" won't. It is true, of course, that for
a long time a 12% coupon did not appear in need of a whole lot of correction.
Must we really view that 12% equity coupon as immutable? Is there any law
that says the corporate return on equity capital cannot adjust itself upward in
response to a permanently higher average rate of inflation? There is no such
law, of course. On the other hand, corporate America cannot increase earnings
by desire or decree. To raise that return on equity, corporations would need at
least one of the following: (1) an increase in turnover, i.e., in the ratio
between sales and total assets employed in the business; (2) cheaper leverage;
(3) more leverage; (4) lower income taxes; (5) wider operating margins on
sales.
And that's it. There simply are no other ways to increase returns on common
equity. Let's see what can be done with these. We'll begin with turnover. The
three major categories of assets we have to think about for this exercise are
accounts receivable, inventories, and fixed assets such as plants and
machinery. Accounts receivable go up proportionally as sales go up, whether the
increase in dollar sales is produced by more physical volume or by inflation.
No room for improvement here.
With inventories, the situation is not quite so simple. Over the long term,
the trend in unit inventories may be expected to follow the trend in unit
sales. Over the short term, however, the physical turnover rate may bob around
because of special influences -- e.g., cost expectations, or bottlenecks.
The use of last-in, first-out (LIFO) inventory-valuation methods serves to
increase the reported turnover rate during inflationary times. When dollar sales are rising because of
inflation, inventory valuations of a LIFO company either will remain
level (if unit sales are not rising) or will trail the rise in dollar
sales (if unit sales are rising). In either case, dollar turnover will
increase.
During the early 1970s, there was a pronounced swing by corporations toward
LIFO accounting (which has the effect of lowering a company's reported earnings
and tax bills). The trend now seems to have slowed. Still, the existence of a
lot of LIFO companies, plus the likelihood that some others will join the
crowd, ensures some further increase in the reported turnover of inventory.
Sumber : ( http://edition.cnn.com/ )
NB : As a group, stock investors can neither
opt out nor renegotiate. (Sebagai kelompok, investor saham tidak dapat memilih keluar atau negosiasi ulang.)
When dollar sales are rising because
of inflation, inventory valuations of a LIFO company either will remain
level (if unit sales are not rising) or will trail the rise in dollar
sales (if unit sales are rising). (Ketika penjualan dolar meningkat karena inflasi, persediaan penilaian dari sebuah perusahaan LIFO akan tetap baik
(jika penjualan unit tidak naik) atau jejak penjualan dolar meningkat (jika penjualan
unit meningkat).
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar